Tasting Notes By Region Islay  |  Islands  |  Campbeltown  |   Speyside   |   Highlands   |  Lowlands
Irish Whiskey  |  Blended, Vatted & Grain  |  American Tasting Notes
Select a Whisky Aberfeldy Aberlour Allt-a-Bhainne Auchentoshan Ardbeg Ardmore Aultmore The Balvenie Banff Ben Nevis Benriach Benromach Benrinnes Bladnoch Blair Athol Bowmore Brora Bunnahabhain Bruichladdich Caol Ila Cardu Clynelish Cragganmore Dailuaine Dallas Dhu The Dalmore Dalwhinnie Deanston Dufftown Glencadam Glen Elgin Glen Grant Glendronach Glenfarclas Glenfiddich Glen Garioch Glengoyne Glen Keith Glenkinchie The Glenlivet Glenmorangie Glen Moray The Glenrothes Glen Scotia Glentauchers Glenturret Glenurgie Highland Park Inchmurrin Interleven Isle of Jura John McDougal Kinclaith Knockando Lagavulin Laphroaig Ledaig Linkwood Linlithgow Loch Lomond Longmorn Longrow Macallan Mannochmore Millburn Mortlach Inchgower Pebble Beach Port Ellen Oban Old Pulteney Rosebank Royal Brackla Royal Lochnagar Speyburn Springbank St. Magadelene Strathisla Strathmill Talisker Tobermory Tomintoul
Recommended by the Whisky Guild For the Collector A good value $ - Under $35          $$ - $35 to $75        $$$ - $75 to $100       $$$$ - $100 to $175       $$$$$ - $175 + If you're new to single malts start with a well balanced Speyside like Craggenmore or The Glenlivet. And remember, the only opinion that truly matters is your own! Cheers, Glen	How to taste whisky Start with a tulip shaded glass (never a whisky tumble). This will concentrate the aroma of the spirit. Nose the whiskey two to three times Take a small sip and let the whisky coat your mouth and note what flavors you pick up Add water to the spirit to open it up and to release the oils in the dram (I add just a splash) Take a big sip and note the overall body of the spirit Move the whisky around in your mouth to pick up additional flavors Swallow and note how long the finish is Take your time and try only a few at a time and drink plenty of water between sips.

Region - Islay

 
Region - Islands
Back to Top

 
Region - Campbeltown
Back to Top

Region - Speyside
Back to Top
 

Aberlour                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Aberlour 10
Glen - 83 I'm a big fan of Aberlour and this one didn't disappoint. Not as sherried as others in the Aberlour range and has more of a maltiness and young feel. Not as big as their other expressions but I liked this one very much. Nose: Sherry, a little young, some light spice, malty Body: Light, fruity & some maltiness Finish: Medium to long, very nice. A nice easy drinking Speyside from a great distillery.	Jeff - 79
Widely available $$
Aberlour                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Aberlour 12
Glen - 74 Not nearly as rich and deep as the 15 year old expression. The 15 is a classic full bodied dram and one of my favorites. The 12 year old is not as complex, comes off a little young and doesn't have the great finish of the 15. You still do have some nice sherry, especially in the nose. And overall it's an honest straightforward dram. I would reach for the 10 year old Aberlour over this dram and both bottles are around the same price.  Nose: Apricots, sherry, clean, grassy, honey, caramel Body: Thick Finish: Short and not very flavorful, some fruit  A nice nose sets you up for a finish that never arrives.	Jeff - 78
Availability at some fine Liquor stores. $$
Aberlour                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Aberlour 15
Glen - 89 Aberlour is a great distillery that produces delicious drams in the heart of Speyside. A big malt that's finished in oloroso Sherry casks. Rich and creamy that has good depth and character. One of my favorite wood finished drams. A winner for those whole like sherry finished scotch.	Jeff - 85 A very woody dram with sherry overtones. the finish is soft with the hint of spicy fruit. A nice whisky on a rainy day
Brett's take: 85 A sherried dram that is much lighter in body than it appears it would be.  Pleasant, nicely balanced malt.  It's a little creamy, a little spicy, but mostly just smooth.  I'm hesitant to call anything a "beginner's malt", first because there's no such thing, but also because the connotation is that it can only get better from there.  However, this is a great malt to introduce people to if they say they don't like whisky.  Even if they do!  Availability at most fine Liquor stores. $$ to $$$
Aberlour                                                                                                                                                Speyside
Aberlour A'Bunadh 'the origin'
Glen - 86 Big and intense, this cask strength powerhouse is a must for the liquor cabinet. Make sure you add water and let this one explode in your mouth. Syrupy sweet with a huge sherry character. This one will sneak up on you so be careful.	Jeff - 91 A'bunadh means original, and it is a replica of an old Aberlour Whisky that was found in a wall in the Aberlour Distillery. A fantastic Whisky that is a great buy for cask strength. A huge nose with apples and fruit. Smells like Apple Pie, how could you not like that.  A creamy fruit rich palate. The finish is smooth with the warmth of honey and smoke.
Availability at most fine Liquor stores. $$ to $$$
Allt-a-Bhainne                                                                                                                                        Speyside
Allt-a-Bhainne 14YO (46%) Duncan Taylor
Glen - 80 A straightforward and respectable Speyside that had a nice warming character. Perfect for a flask on a cold day. This dram perked up nicely with a touch of water. My only complaint was a lingering bitter aftertaste. Nose: Light, malty, honey, butter, fresh Body: Medium Finish: Explodes in the mouth, long and spicy, butterscotch, warming A nice everyday type of dram	Brett - 82 A beautiful fresh, malty nose that softly explodes with honey butter. There is also the essence of those hard peppermint candies that you get in diners. It's a sharp segue to the palate, which is medium weight, very spicy, and perhaps a bit young. This whisky's finish, though, recalls its start (as all good whiskies should), with echoes of butterscotch and candy caramels. The medium-long finish also strangely seemed a little "fizzy", although this couldn't be understood by any of us. Nonetheless, a very nice dram.
Limited. $$$ to $$$$
Ardmore                                                                                                                                                    Speyside
Ardmore
Glen -	Jeff - 90 Editor's Pick Spring 2008 This peated Speyside whisky really surprised me. Normally only bottled by independents, Ardmore (founded in 1898) finally came out with its own bottling. Every time I hear of a peated Speysider, I start to wince. But leave it to a Speyside distillery that has always peated their fine nectar. This robust campfire dram almost makes you forget about that little Island on the west coast of Scotland. Clean peat smoke, if there is such a thing! Like a nice campfire in autum, with full-bodied, earthy richness. subtle sweetness, and a lingering finish. Very Nice - Well Done!
Available at some fine liquor stores. $$
Aultmore                                                                                                                                                      Speyside
Aultmore 1992 15 yr old 46% (Small Batch) The Single Malts of Scotland www.thewhiskyexchange.com
Glen - 84 An easy drinker that wasn't overly complex, just pleasant and unassuming. The nose was the highlight of the trip with notes of butterscotch, burnt sugar and peaches. The body was somewhat light but still flavorful while the finish was medium length with more oak coming through. Nose: Deep, butterscotch, burnt sugar, malt, peaches, touch of oak Body: Light and flavorful Finish: Medium length, malt and oak, butterscotch, lemon rind, warming Approachable.	Brett -
Available at www.thewhiskyexchange.com $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                             Speyside
The Balvenie 12 yr Doublewood 43%
Glen - 83 This classic Balvenie has a wonderful nose full of oranges and honey. The sherry doesn't overpower the dram and adds just the right amount of character. My only complaint was the finish came off a tad bitter; but it did have a nice, warming character. Nose: Classic, oranges, honey, subtle malt, clean, spicy Body: Heavy Finish: Medium and big at first, some bite without water, sherry, warming, a tad bitter The classic Balvenie.	Jeff - 74 Has a nice cinnamon spiciness to it with a sherry finish. This dram has a nice finish but not very balanced.
Brett's take: Rating 83 Opens with a nose full of orange zest, but also vanilla, malt, caramel, and spice (ginger, cinnamon). The Double Wood's aroma is also slightly "biscuity", recalling a kitchen after baking. A medium mouthfeel, presages a medium-long, sweet finish of sherry, honey, malt, and some oak at the very end. And oranges. You'd better like oranges. Available at most liquor stores. $$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                             Speyside
The Balvenie 15 yr Single Barrel 47.8%
Glen - 80 Updated Jan, 2008 At first the nose seemed younger then that 12 year old Doublewood expression but improved with water and the longer the dram stayed in the glass.  Had a slightly bitter aftertaste that was consistent with others in the range. Very similar to the 12 year old but lacked that little extra the sherry imparts. Nose: Grassy without water, fresh, vanilla, fruity, oak Body: Heavy Finish: Long and sharp without water, warming, a tad bitter This one needs water.	Brett - 84 A scintillating nose! It is fresh, eye-opening, and invigorating; grassy and lemony, with big malt and hints of allspice. Good Morning! Unfortunately, this dram quickly says goodnight. It is, unsurprisingly, medium-light on the palate, but unfortunately a little too short in the finish. Maybe not unfortunately. Unless you like peppery heat mixed with marsh grass and bitter orange zest. (Since the 15 YO expression is from a single barrel, and each barrel produces only 300+ bottles of whisky, it goes without saying that almost each bottle you buy will probably be a little different. In fact, some of the best Balvenie's that I've had have been from the 15 YO expression. This particular bottle was not one of them. Do not let that sway you - my past experience convinces me that this bottle was an anomaly. I hope.)
Available at most liquor stores. $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                             Speyside
The Balvenie 12 Year Old (Signature) batch 001 (43%):
Glen -	Brett - 89 A very tight nose, but also exceedingly "clean". Oranges are replaced by apple skins, which harmonize nicely with honey, vanilla, and freshly baked bread. Medium-bodied, the Signature also has a very warming, medium-length finish, replete with orange creams, peach pits, (very) light peat, Fruity Pebbles, homestyle biscuits, and light spiciness. I always look for a whisky's finish and nose to complement each other. These do; and quite nicely
Limited. $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                                Speyside
The Balvinie Rum Cask 17 year old
Glen - 84 Big rum profile balanced nicely by Balvenie's full rich character. A lovely nose with hints of nectarines, apricots, and vanilla (once you get past all that beautiful rum). Nose: Rum, nectarines, apricots, nutty, vanilla Body: Medium and soft Finish Medium length, rum, bitter oranges, honey Balvenie on a Caribbean vacation	Brett - 82 Rum!!! Nosing this dram, I felt like throwing-on an eye patch, swinging the bottle around, and giving a little Yo Ho Ho. It's almost that overpowering. But, shiver me timbers, there is more to it. Avast (sorry, I get carried away), there's also fresh nuts, vanilla wafers, and nectarines lurking in this inviting aroma. The body is medium-weight, and the finish medium-length, with distinct flavors dueling for prominence: the bitter of quinine and orange zest vs. the sweet of honey and fruitcake. An interesting dram, for when you want something different. Aye, me hearties?
Availability at some fine liquor stores. $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                                Speyside
The Balvinie SherryOak  17 year old
Glen - 87 Nov, 2007 This Balvenie is matured exclusively in sherry casks. This one will be a treat for Balvenie fans who rarely get a chance to buy a Balvenie that's been aged exclusively in sherry. The sherry is well balanced and not overdone. Plenty of other flavors peek through, like, pumpkin spice, toasted nuts, and fruit. A very nice and enjoyable Balvenie. Nose: Sherry, pumpkin spice, toasted nuts, fruity Body: Medium to full, flavorful Finish: Long and spicy, dry and complex Very flavorful and smooth. A good Fall/Winter dram.	Brett - 90 I'm usually not a fan of BIG sherry drams - I find them overpowering. This dram is an exception. It is beautifully textured and, although the sherry is completely to the fore, it is far from oppressive. In fact, this limited edition release is remarkably fresh, allowing all of its olfactory friends to come out and play: almonds (roasted and fresh), well-oiled leather, balsamic vinegar, and gorgeous oak. Given the sherry, the body was lighter than I imagined it would be (which is not to say it was light, at all). The finish to this expression was no less luxurious: vanilla, lemon crème, and butter-almond ice cream. And a little sherry, of course. My advice (for what it's worth): get a bottle, before they're gone!
Availability at some fine liquor stores. $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                                Speyside
The Balvenie Port Wood 1993
Glen -	Jeff - 69 This whisky has a great nose and I'm afraid it ends there. A whisky that doesn't live up to its nose. The oak almost overpowers the whisky.
Availability at some fine Liquor stores. $$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                                Speyside
The Balvenie Port Wood 21 year old 43%
Glen - 91 Jan, 2008 An amazingly subtle and elegant whisky that's the best of the standard Balvenie range. A wonderful nose filled with tropical fruit is followed up with a smooth body and long finish. Has great balance. Very well done. Nose: Fresh, subtle oak, tropical fruit, banana taffy, some spice Body: Medium and smooth Finish: Long and smooth, warming A great dram.	Jeff - 92 I could drink this whisky all day and night. I feel the finest in the range and I feel one of the better buys on the market today. the rich body with taffy, rich spiciness is just fantastic. The port does come threw on the finish that is smooth and long.
Brett's Take: Rating - 83 The Port Wood starts out with the traditional Balvenie aroma of oranges and oak, but the port pipes add so much more: raspberries, honey, a sweetness somewhere between saccharin and marzipan, and above all, depth. Like most Balvenies, the Port Wood has a medium-weight body, but the finish is now starting to stretch-out. And that's a good thing, because this finish is full. With a mélange of mixed, salted nuts, sweet malt, bitter orange, light peat, fresh toffee, and recollections of a summer orchard, this is one 21 year old who's all grown up. Availability at some fine Liquor stores. $$$$
The Balvenie                                                                                                                                                Speyside
The Balvenie 25 year old Single Barrel
Glen -	Brett - 91 This one starts off a little musty, as of tired oak; but it's hardly exhausted. The nose quickly perks up to aromas of roasted nuts, sandalwood, simple syrup, and a mix of mint and barley. It's almost intoxicating. This 25 YO is very full-bodied, especially for a Balvenie, and also has quite a long finish; a nice treat. And what a finish! Full of more roasted nuts, toasted oak, maple syrup, breakfast sausage, a healthy dose of peat, and (lest we forget) hints of bitter orange. This is the only expression which I've reviewed here that is, sadly, no longer available. I put it in, in the hopes that you can find a bottle on a dusty shelf somewhere. When you do, thank me.
Limited. $$$$$
Benriach                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Benriach 10
Glen - 78 An easy drinking straightforward dram that came off nice enough. Not to complex and a little thin and bitter on the finish. This is an older Benriach and was bottled before the new ownership took over. Today Benriach is turning out exciting new expressions but this relic from that past is still pleasant and worth a pull. Has a nice nose but it doesn't follow through to the finish. Nose: Malt, fresh, cut grass, heather Body: surprisingly chewy Finish: Medium length, butterscotch, bitter, warming Straightforward.	Jeff - 86 A nice relaxed whisky that should be slowly enjoyed for its subtle complexity and overall character. A full bodied Whisky that gets better with each sip.
Very limited availability. $$
Benriach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Benriach 16
Glen - 88 A wonderful dram with amazing depth and character. Smokey for a Speyside with hints of malt, spices and honey. A winner from this newly independent distillery. A little pricey but worth every penny.	Jeff - 89 A creamy smooth dram that surprises you how good it really is. A well balanced and complex Speyside, with a touch of smoke to finish this truly hidden gem!
Very limited availability. $$
Benriach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Benriach 10 'Curiositas' Peated
Glen - 84 Heavily peated but not over done. Has a great balance of sweetness and peat. A truly unique Speyside that's worth discovering. .	Jeff - 83 Well balanced despite that strong peat taste. This is an interesting dram, I must say I think I would enjoy it more if it had a different name. I find myself comparing it to the 16 which is really not fair..
Available at most Liquor stores. $$
Benriach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Benriach 1984 22 yr old 53.2% (Single Cask/Cask Strength) The Single Malts of Scotland www.thewhiskyexchange.com
Glen - 70 Jan 2008 A Speyside trying it's hardest to be and Islay and falling way short. A one trick pony that was all smoke and peat but had no sweetness to balance things out. A tough one. Nose: Smoke, peat, gauze, iodine, dry packaged cake mix Body: Medium Finish: Medium length, dry ash, peat, smoke, gauze aftertaste All smoke and peat but not in a good way.	Jeff -
Available at www.thewhiskyexchange.com $$$
Benrinnes                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Benrinnes 15 year old Flora Fauna
Glen - 73 Nov 2008 I was intrigued by this mahogony colored dram as it sat on the shelves of the Oban distillery shop, so I just had to pick it up. The old Flora & Fauna line usually never disappoints so I was fairly comfortable with my purchase even though I never actually tried the liquid inside. Unfortunately, the experience of buying this dram outweighed its contents. The dram was unbalanced with an overabundance of sherry and youthful grassiness, and much too much heat in the finish. It does improve with a heavy pour of water. Nose: Grassy and youthful, bitter sherry, bittersweet chocolate, orange peel Body: Soft, velvety Finish: Long, very sharp and drying, stays with you (but not in a good way), malty, oak, sherry, vanilla Nothing really appealing with this one.	Jeff -
Not available in the US $$
Benromach                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Benromach 18 Year Old
Glen - 78 This dram seemed to change in my glass. At first it was a little harsh but mellowed nicely after the first few sips. It has a heavy port wine nose and has some fire on the palate and finish. The dram is a little rough and hot but in a good way. It opens up well with water and grows on you like a comfortable old coat. Let this one sit in your glass for a minute or two after adding a touch of water. Nose: Straightforward, port wine, some chocolate and over ripe fruit Body: Chewy Finish: Some bite, lingering and dry, unique A big beefy malt.	Jeff - 71
Available at some fine liquor stores. $$
Cardu                                                                                                                                                Speyside
Cardu 12
Glen - 80 A well rounded Speyside that is very typical for the region. A big part of the Johnnie Walker blends. A light delicate malt that is solid but not very complex.	Jeff - 81 The first distillery to be started by a woman. This is the heart of Johnnie Walker Red. Cardu is short and gets to the point quick. Not a whisky that has a long finish. But, a good dram none the less.
Available at some fine Liquor stores. $$$
Cragganmore                                                                                                                                      Speyside
Cragganmore 12 (a Classic Malt Selection)
Glen - 85 A great dram that's very reasonably priced. A well balanced whisky that screams Speyside. Cragganmore represents that region like no other. Delicate but complex and a great dram for the beginner. This is the malt that introduced me to Single Malt Scotch. Nose: Fresh and fragrant, floral and grassy Body: Light Body: Medium to long, very smooth and flavorful A truly classic malt.	Jeff - 89 Its hard to find something not to like about Cragganmore. A well balanced whisky that has a great nose, with honey and toffee notes. A silky smooth texture with a beautiful finish. You would be hard pressed to find a better single malt at this price.
Brett's take: Rating 81 Cragganmore 12:  "Hard to find something not to like?"  How about, it's thin, not fragrant enough, and the interesting banana notes at the first taste are drowned out by formaldehyde.  The label says it has the most complex aroma of any malt.  Right.  Take a walk next door to Glenfarclas and nose something there, then decide. Still, it was the first single I ever tried, so I have a soft spot in my little heart for it, and continually try it to see if either it or I have improved.  Available at most liquor stores. $$
Cragganmore                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Cragganmore Distiller's Edition
Glen - 86 A well balanced complex whisky with strong citrus flavors. Not as good as it's widely available brother but very good none the less.	Jeff - 92 I feel the best distillers additions of the classic malts. The ports cask adds a subtle sweetness to this beautiful dram. A very complex whisky, that is hard to figure out. But, when a whisky is this good who cares, just sit back and enjoy.
Available at some Liquor stores. $$
Cragganmore                                                                                                                                         Speyside
Cragganmore 29
Glen - 90 A truly exceptional dram produced in very limited quantity. Liquid gold that warms the soul. Has all of the complexity that you could ever hope for in a Speyside.	Jeff - 91 This grassy sweet little number reminds me that making whisky is all about great care and love. The delicate dry body fills your mouth and makes you want more. This Whisky will most definitely be a collectors item in years to come
Available at very few Liquor stores. $$$$$
Dailuaine                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Dailuaine Flora Fauna
Glen - 88 A rich and robust smoky Speyside. Dailuaine offers wonderful depth and its rich and warming character make it the perfect cold-weather dram. This one should come with a fireplace and a premium cigar. It noses like a rich Speyside and finishes like a great smoky Highland. Perfect balance. Nose: Clean and rich, oak, sherry, touch of smoke, sweet, cherry cordials, a touch of peat to round it off Body: Medium and smooth Finish: Long and dry, smoky, sharp and warming A brilliant dram.	Jeff - 94 One of the most balanced whiskies you'll ever try. Almost perfect in everyway.  Very smooth and clean with a nice sherry balance. If you can find it, don't let it out of your sight
Brett's take: Rating 86 Dailuaine 16:  Caution:  This is not a summer dram - Drink this only in winter!  Very thick, sherry sweet, almost syrupy.  You still catch oak and malt, but it is so big and full that it is definitely not the refreshing aperitif you'd want on a hot day.  While usually not my style, there's something about Dailuaine that just makes you smile.  The crime, that this is not sold in US. If you get your hands on this beauty, you won't be sorry $$
Dallas Dhu                                                          Silent Still                                                             Speyside
Dallas Dhu 27 year old cask strength Dun Bheagan
Glen - 94 An incredible dram that's finished in Rum casks. The whisky is very complex and the rum doesn't over power it. The nose was full of oranges and vanilla and of coarse rum. The body was medium and chewy and the finish is long and amazing. Had a creamy quality that I loved. This one had me at hello. Nose: Complex, oranges, vanilla ice cream, sweet, rum Body: Medium, chewy Finish: long, sweet and smooth, the rum gets in the back of the throat Special!	Jeff - 93
Not widely available $$$$$
Dufftown                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Dufftown 15 year old Flora Fauna
Glen - 78 A good but uninspired dram that had a very good nose but a bitter aftertaste. The nose was sweet and fresh but the finish was grassy and hot. Good but not great. Nose: Rosewater, sweet, fresh & clean, menthol Body: Medium Finish: Long & drying, grassy, hot A good but uninspired dram.	Jeff - 80
Not available in the US $$ to $$$
Dufftown                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Macduff Duncan Taylor 1969 54.4% cask# 3682
Glen - 82 With a name like Macduff, I'm sure this would be Homer's Simpson's choice if he drank Scotch. A good straightforward whisky that had a pleasant menthol character. I've never met a Macduff that I really loved but this one gave it a college try. A light nose dominated by sherry and oak. A medium flavorful body but a harsh and slightly bitter finish left me at the alter. Dohhhh! Nose: Light & subtle, sherry, oak, fresh fruit, menthol Body: Medium Finish: Short but lingers, menthol, vanilla, slightly harsh and bitter, peppermint candy, a burst of heat at the end Comes close but the finish spoils a good time.	Jeff -
Limited $$$
Glendronach                                                                                                                                       Speyside
Glendronach 12
Glen - 79 A good dram that grows on you. The finish has a nice punch at the end. Nose: Malty, strong vanilla character Body: Medium, oily Finish: Dry, light, fruity, nice bite at the end Has some character and attitude.	Jeff - 79 This sherried whisky has hints raisins with a surprising peat aroma. The medium body lacks some complexity, but has a nice sherried finish.
Available at some Liquor stores. $$
Glen Elgin                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Glen Elgin 12
Glen - 77 The nose will fool you on this dram. I felt let down after smelling the whisky since it has an exceptional nose. The body and finish improve greatly with water. Nose: Honey, fruit, a great nose! Body: Medium, hot, not smooth Finish: Short	Jeff - 82 I agree with Glen on this one, One of the nicest noses around, honey, pears with hint of fruit fill your nose, But it stops there. The body doesn't live up being a little firm. The finish is nice and dry.
Available at some Liquor stores. $$
Glen Elgin                                                                                                                                                Speyside
Glen Elgin 1980 Scotts 44.1%
Glen - 86 Dec,2007 A nice subtle and sweet dram that 's very easy drinking and enjoyable. Scotts seems to never disappoint and didn't with this one. All their whiskies are solid. It had a very light flavorful nose and a wonderful dry finish. A very solid and approachable dram. Nose: Soft and light, nutty, honey, very faint maltiness Body: Medium, creamy Finish: Medium length and dry, flavorful Easy drinking and enjoyable.	Jeff - 81
Limited. $$$$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Glenfarclas 12
Glen - 84 One of the last independent distilleries left and produces some of the finest whisky in the world. The 12 year old is a full bodied whisky with fruit and oak notes. A good dram but totally over shadowed by its older brothers. Nose: Sweet Body: Dry, some fruit, rich Finish: Big and then leaves in a hurry A big sweet after dinner dram	Jeff - 86 A great whisky with hints of honey. A well balanced dram at a great price. I don't think Glenfarclas could make a bad whisky even if they tried. Voted the best Distillery in "06 and for good reason.
Brett's take: Rating A light nose; malty; minty; fresh. A mild, slightly oily body; young, but without that "tequila" aldehyde taste that can sometimes mar other young whiskies. A light sherry finish, I found it shorter than my co-tasters did. An excellent "straight-ahead" malt. Available at some Liquor stores. $$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfarclas 17
Glen - 97 One of my favorites. Reasonably priced at under $100 for such impressive malt. Honey notes and a smoothness you only find in whiskies much older. Just melts in your mouth with a warm finish. Truly an exceptional dram.    Nose: Sherry, oak, butterscotch Body: Rich, full Finish: Dry sherry, malty  Add a little water to bring out the smoke. Goes from good to great with a touch of water.	Jeff - 96 Wow!! This one is a winner, I feel it is the best Glenfarclas regardless of age. Sweet, malty with spicy notes, one of the true great whiskies. Should be a must for every Whisky connoisseur.
Brett's take: Rating 91 An absolutely super dram.  Complex!  I'm not a sherry guy, but this is beautiful, playing against the malt and oak.  You can almost taste those candies that grandpa kept in his pockets.  Just buy a bottle, and then send me a thank you note.  In my mind, Glenfarclas only surpassed this with its 1968 vintage.  Limited availability. $$$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfarclas 21
Glen - 83 I picked up a musty sweetness in this dram and lots of hay. It was like sipping a dram on a rainy day on the porch of an old farmhouse. Some subtle smoke on the nose and orange zest in the finish made this dram a nice well balance Speyside. The finish was a little short but the nose made the journey well worth it. Nose: Musty, rich and fruity sweet, subtle peat, sherry, oak Body: Syrupy but still some what light Finish: Short, orange zest, some heat and a touch of smoke A nice well balanced Speyside	Brett - 84 A "candy-sweet" nose, with light smoke, more sherry, malt, and oak. We found the 21 to have a slightly bigger body than the 17, with a finish of oranges and a little heat, which made it seem somehow younger than the 17. Crazy, we know, but it was interesting.
Limited availability. $$$$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfarclas 25
Glen - 90 Updated Oct 2008 This is one big, rich, and syrupy Speyside. Aged to perfection with a wonderful nose that's filled to the brim with vanilla, malt, and butterscotch. You pick up malt and oak throughout the dram that complement the sweeter flavors perfectly. If you like big, rich Speysides, then this one's a must. A perfect dram to sip by the fire, in the cold winter months. Nose: Dominated by vanilla and malt, butterscotch, maple syrup, sweet oak, a touch of smoke Body: Thick and smooth Finish: Some bite, oak and malt, vanilla A big beautiful dram.	Jeff - 87 Reminds me of a great desert at a gourmet restaurant. It has a very nice nose filled with cherries and honey. This whisky I feel is overshadowed by Its younger brother.
Brett's take: Rating 89 A big fruity nose (raspberries?), with peppermints, vanilla, an underpinning of hay. A medium-to-large body, with bittersweet chocolate on the palate. The finish is long and lingering, and somehow reminded me of dandelion wine. This is a whisky that "oozes" maturity. Super! Limited availability. $$$$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfarclas 105
Glen - 88 A well balanced cask strength whisky. Hints of chocolate and has a big sherry character. Cask strength so make sure you cut it with water.	Jeff - 84 If you like cask strength whiskies this one is for you. Big sherry flavor fills this powerful dram. Just make sure you cut it with water or your going to have a long night.
Brett's take: Rating A nose of maple syrup and fresh butter; with water, the nose opens-up with a youthful floral freshness. A nice full body, with ripe bananas dancing on the palate. A medium-to-long finish, which perfectly complements this elegant whisky. Limited availability. $$$
Glenfarclas                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfarclas 1968
Glen - 93 This is one big rich Glenfarclas that's syrupy sweet and very complex. It took me a little while to really dive in to this dram. It overpowers the senses when you first savor it. Had a tough deep character that grows on you after each sip. Reminded me of the 25 year old taken to the next level. A sherry monster that's best enjoyed after a gourmet meal. Nose: Heavy sherry, Burnt caramel, almonds, chocolate Body: Thick & Syrupy Finish: Long and dry, fruity, fresh clover honey, bity, smoky A dram to be savored on cold nights around the fire.	Jeff - 88
Rare. $$$$$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                         Speyside
Glenfiddich12
Glen - 85 Where it all started and one of the most popular whiskies in the world. Hints of vanilla and a mild nuttiness. Has that distinctive Glenfiddich maltiness.  A great everyday malt.	Jeff - 86 A well rounded malt that was one of the pioneers into the American market. This is the first single malt I ever tried. I can still remember taking the screws off my fathers liquor cabinet only to find Glenfiddich whisky. So, you can say I acquired a taste early for scotch.
Available at all liquor stores. $$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfiddich 12 Toasted Oak limited reserve
Glen - 88 Matured in specially toasted American oak bourbon barrels gives this dram a great smooth sweet character. I found it very different from the standard malty flavor that typify other Glenfiddich expressions. This whisky was easy drinking and very flavorful. A drink all day type of dram. A nice sweet treat. Nose: Classic Glenfiddich oak, honey & caramel, nutty, some spice, had a great fresh nose Body: Thick and syrupy Finish: Medium length, smooth and nutty, flavorful A beauty.	Jeff - 86
Not available in the US. $$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfiddich 15
Glen - 86 Updated May 2008 After recently seeing Glenfiddich's Solera Vat in person I just had to sample this often overlooked Glenfiddich once again. I've always enjoyed this expression but until actually nosing and getting a few fingers wet in the Solera Vat, which of course was a total accident, I've come to appreciate this dram even more. A nice deep and complex nose of chocolate, honey, and vanilla give way to a smooth flavorful body and medium length finish. A whisky that's perfect for sharing with friends even if they aren't experienced Single Malt drinkers. Overall, the dram was well balanced, flavorful and with just enough complexity.  Has that 'throw  the cork in the fire' type of feel. Nose: A brilliant nose, orange chocolates, malt, honey, vanilla, oak, vibrant Body: Medium, smooth and malty Finish: Medium length, spicy, classic Glenfiddich oak,  malt, vanilla, very smooth Well balanced and enjoyable and one you'll reach for often.	Jeff -
Available at most high end liquor stores. $$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfiddich 18
Glen - 89 A great elegant and complex malt. Oak, honey and some fruit make this a well balanced winner.	Jeff - 91 A delicate whisky that should be savored. The hint of fruit with a bit of smooth smokiness is a great compliment. Reminds me of that girlfriend that got away.
Available at most fine liquor stores. $$ to $$$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                              Speyside
Glenfiddich Caoran
Glen - 91 A big whisky that's like nothing else in the Glenfiddich range. Caoran "ku-ran" is Gaelic for peat amber, but you'll have to wait for the finish for the peat to really shine. This whisky is finished in casks that were used to mature Islay whisky, making it one unique Glenfiddich. Very well balanced and a beautiful marriage between Speyside and Islay. Nose: Sweet, very malty, subtle smoke, oranges Body: Thick and syrupy Finish: Dry and long, peat, earthy Takes Glenfiddich to the next level.	Jeff - 93 Who ever thought of this idea marring Laphroaig casks with Glenfiddich was a genius and deserves a raise. Unlike its older 21 year old brother. This whisky has it all and is a must for any collector or person who loves just plain old great whisky.
The crime, that this is not sold in US. If you get your hands on this beauty, you won't be sorry $$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfiddich 21 Cuban Rum Finish (This is the Cuban Rum finish, which is not available in the US)
Glen - 81 Finished in Cuban Rum casks make this malt a truly unique dram. A good dram that is more of a curiosity than others in the Glenfiddich range.	Jeff - 85 More of a collectors whisky then anything. The Cuban Rum casks provide a nice sweetness to it, but I wish this process was done with a younger whisky that could stand up to the rum, not drown in it.
Not sold in US. $$$$
Glenfiddich                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenfiddich 30
Glen - 96 In my opinion this is one of the greatest whisky in the world. A gentle elegant dram that should be savored and appreciated slowly. Honey notes and light smoke make this complex dram oh so smooth.	Jeff - 98 One of the best whiskies a man could slowly savor. Worth every penny, the only thing is once you take a sip your hooked. One of the best whiskies in the world and from one of the nicest distilleries I've had the pleasure of visiting.
Available at fine liquor stores. $$$$$
Glen Keith                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Glen Isla (Glen Keith Distillery) Signatory 1977 29 Year old
Glen - 87 Glen Isla is no longer produced and has become incredibly rare. We were fortunate enough to try this Signatory bottling at a recent event and it was well worth the train ride into the City. The nose was fresh, clean and complex with notes of vanilla, caramel, heather. The body was light and the dram had a nice long sweet smoky finish. A very different whisky. Nose: Complex, vanilla, caramel, heather, fresh, clean Body: Light but had some legs Finish: Long, fruity, sweet smoke Enjoyable.	Jeff -
Rare $$$$$
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                      Speyside
Glenlivet 12
Glen - 82 Updated July, 2008 This is one of the most popular whiskies in the world and played a big part of introducing America if not the world to the wonders of Single Malt Scotch. Approachable and honest sums up this easy going Speyside. A tad tight but overall nice nose dominated by oak and oranges gives way to a light and smooth body and short but flavorful finish. A good introduction to The Glenlivet. Nose: Oak, oranges, malt, vanilla, dried hay, peaches, pumpkin spice Body: Light and smooth Finish: Short with a big initial burst of oak, peaches A good and honest dram.	Jeff - 83 The Glenlivet has an exceptional nose with loads of character, it's soft rounded body is nice to help drink the sorrows away, with a nice warming finish. A well priced whisky that is easy to find.
Brett's Take: A fairly tight nose. Oaky and malty, with lots of fruit notes (oranges and peaches). There is also an apple spiciness and hints of honey-soaked ladyfingers. A medium-to-light body gives way to an equally medium-length finish, full of vanilla, malt, dry oak, and fresh nuts. Although it doesn't seem to handle water well, it doesn't need to. The Glenlivet's omnipresent classic. (Rating: 81) Available at all liquor stores. $
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
The Glenlivet 15 French Oak Reserve
Glen - 77 July, 2008 I'm normally a big fan of The Glenlivet but this dram never grabbed me. A very light whisky that left you with the feeling of; 'is that it'? A very light nose, a very light body and a very short finish. Do I see a pattern developing? Not a bad dram but do yourself a favor and grab the 12 year old and save some cash. Nose: Musty, black tea, oak, vanilla, honey, fresh and floral Body: Light, a whisper Finish: Very short, oak and peaches, warming Underwhelming.	Brett - 80 Working with French Oak can be challenging. This dram is no exception, with an interesting mix at work on the nose. At times slightly bitter, with light musk, white tea, orange zest, light oak, and notes of creampuffs, this is an unusual mélange. The body surprised by being so light, and the finish by being so short, but not unpleasantly so, as it was also quite spicy with notes of dried hay, more oak, and an interesting fruit compote. A different Glenlivet.
Widely available $$ to $$$
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
The Glenlivet 18
Glen - 92 Updated June 2008 A perfect Speyside whisky where the oak really shines through. This dram is one of my all time favorites for it's exceptional depth and complexity. The nose begins with sweet oak and malt, with hints of honey and vanilla until buttered toast and a floral character come through. The body is oaky and smooth while the finish is long and warming with more oak and honey. Perfect neat that I love to order as a starter to a fine meal. A fine and luxurious whisky. First rate and matured to perfection. Highly recommended. Nose: Sweet oak and malt, honey, vanilla, raisins, buttered toast, floral Body: Medium mouth feel, smooth and oaky Finish: Long and warming, oak and honey     The perfect Speyside.	Jeff - 87 If you like the nose on the 12 you'll love this one. A nice complex whisky that is raw and not overdone. A sweet nutty body fills your mouth with a long finish something its younger brother is missing.
Brett's Take: An extremely complex dram, with an exceptional nose of sweet cream, oranges, fresh meadows, butterscotch, vanilla beans, and oodles of honey. The satisfying medium-weight mouthfeel is nicely followed-up by a finish as complex as the nose. Slightly tannic and with moderate heat, the finish shows good length while showcasing orange zest, anisette toasts, lemons, oak, and a buttery smoothness at the last. Very well-balanced! That being said, I admit that I'm in the minority here. This is a very (underline very) good dram. But when speaking of The Glenlivet, most people treat this expression as the Second Coming. I must have been looking the other way. Quite a good dram; and a good value, yes. Raising Lazarus from the dead and walking on water, well… (Rating: 83) Widely available $$ to $$$ A very good bargain
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
The Glenlivet N'adurra 16 year old
Glen - 89 N'adurra (Gaelic for Natural) is a new cask strength whisky from The Glenlivet distillery. This one is much more powerful and flavorful then others in their range, even after you add water. The flavors are tight and very pronounced. I love their 18 year old expression for its smoothness and subtle flavors and I liked this one for the opposite reasons. I cut the whisky with a healthy pour of water and it enhanced the dram immensely. Nose: Nutty, vanilla and honey Body: Hot, untamed, medium bodied Finish: Long and dry with hints of fresh fruit and a whiff of smoke A great dram!	Brett - 91 Attention purists: this whisky is cask strength and non-chill filtered. So have your water at the ready, though Nadurra is so smooth, you may not need it. The nose on this beauty possesses a honey and corn sweetness, with vanilla, coffee beans, apples, summer fruits, peppermints, and melting sugar. If you do add water, also notice the fresh hay and the tobacco. The purity of the malt assures a heavy mouthfeel, and the finish, also, does not disappoint. Medium-long, with a nice fizzy tingle, Nadurra is, by turns, oaky, and sweet, with big notes of maple syrup, ginger candies, and The Glenlivet's ever-present oranges. A must have.
Newly imported into the US $$ to $$$
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
The Glenlivet 21
Glen - 88 Updated July, 2008 The few extra years of maturation really add a nice richness and depth to this whisky. Surprisingly, I get less oak; even though it's aged longer than its younger siblings. The nose is complex but comes off musty, with notes of orange, cinnamon, and vanilla. The mouthfeel is light and tingly while the finish is medium-length with some bite. The finish is where the oak comes through, along with peach pits, honey, and anise. A nice, high-end Glenlivet. Nose: Musty, deep, oranges, cinnamon, vanilla Body: Light and tingly Finish: Medium with some bite, oak, peach pits, honey, anise Nice complexity and depth.	Jeff - 81 At first I really enjoyed its firm body but it lost me at hello. The maltiness took over and I could never recover.
Brett's Take: From the first sniff, you can tell that this one's different. Gone (almost) are the floral notes that are such a hallmark of The Glenlivet as to be almost not worth mentioning - except when they're not there. In their place lies a heavier, sweeter, more sherried nose; musty, with scents of cooked tomatoes, sugar cane, orange peel, malt, cinnamon, and vanilla. Given the heaviness of the nose, you would expect a body that overwhelms your mouth, but the medium-weight is, instead, a pleasant surprise. As is the medium-long finish, which complements the nose nicely, with lots of oak, more orange peel, honey, peach pits, anise, and tanned leather. A very contemplative dram; possibly too heavily sherried for some, but it suits me just fine (and I'm not usually a sherry "guy"). (Rating: 88) Available at most liquor stores. $$$$
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
The Glenlivet 25 (New release Summer 2008)
Glen -	Brett - 92 A deep nose, requiring full immersion for its appreciation. Sherried, without being overly so, with notes of cooked peaches, raisins, oak, burnt sugar, and a hint of oranges - the ultimate dessert. Medium-bodied, the 25 year old has a satisfying long finish; creamy, yet drier than I expected, with dark chocolate, honey, spices (especially cinnamon and allspice), and, of course, more oranges. This whisky is definitely a luxurious treat. Possibly, this is the Second Coming? If not, it should still be treated reverentially. Worth the money.
Not yet available. $$$$$
The Glenlivet                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Glenlivit, 1968, bottled 3-5-07, cask 6199 (52.1%) Duncan Taylor
Glen - 79 An ancient Glenlivet that's heavily sherried. Reminded me of Duncan Taylor's Glen Grant 34 year old but without the great balance. Any time you can get your hands on a Glenlivet this old it's a good day but I found the sherry a little overpowering and bitter. This is still a big flavorful whisky that had a rugged character and a wonderful nose. The finish was a little short but still very flavorful. Maybe I was just expecting way too much. Nose: Reminded me of the 18th green, fresh, tobacco, leather, ancient sherry and oak Body: Chewy to medium Finish: Short with sherry overwhelming other notes, fruity and hot A little over aged.	Brett - 78 Another very aged, sherried dram, this Glenlivit oozed old leather and wild grasses, and was at once both rugged and tamed. The body on this one was exceptionally big, full of a mix of fresh fruits. Its finish was a little surprising, though: medium-short, and bursting with (very) tart cherries. Warming, but a little abrupt. Still nice to get our hands on an older Glenlivit, though, and enjoy what a little extra time can do.
Limited. $$$$
Glen Moray                                                                                                                                              Speyside
Glen Moray 12 yr old Chanin Blanc Finish 40%
Glen - 78 Dec/2007 An interesting dram that's finished in Chenin Blanc wine casks. I didn't care for the nose , which came off grassy but was balanced by oak and malt. The wine is pronounced throughout the dram and adds a nice appealing dimension. Enjoyable enough but I wouldn't go back for more. Nose: Sharp, grassy, fresh, floral, crushed green grapes, oak and malt, a touch of vanilla Body: Medium and lively Finish: Long and sharp, very crisp, oak, green grapes, winey The Chenin Blanc adds a nice twist.	Jeff - 80
Limited. $$
Glenrothes                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Glenrothes 1989
Glen - 87 Quality and craftsmanship is what Glenrothes is all about and this dram is a perfect example of that. I didn't want this bottle to end and now it is difficult to find. An easy drinking well balanced Speyside. Nose: Dried fruit, delicate, some spice, a great nose Body: Light but has some legs Finish: Long and flavorful, nice and warming A smooth well balanced, every day kind of dram	Jeff - 87
Limited availability $$
Glenrothes                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Glenrothes 1991 43%
Glen - 86 Jan, 2008 I always think of The Glenrothes as the 'thinking mans dram'. At first blush it's ok but doesn't wow you, but the more you dive in the more impressive it gets and more character it reveals. The 1991 expression exemplifies that. At first you're hit with Aldehyde which I don't care for but behind it you have wonderful depth and flavor. The body is rich while the finish is smooth and outstanding. Seems to melt away in your mouth. Nose: Aldehyde at first, fruit, orange zest, deep Body: Big and rich, chewy, wonderful mouthfeel Finish: Medium length, very smooth and elegant, exceptional First rate with an exceptional finish	Jeff - 87
Widely availability $$
Glenrothes                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glenrothes 30 year old The Macphail's Collection
Glen - 91 Complex and deep this malt has some character. By far the best Glenrothes I've tried and one that should be a must for any Glenrothes fan. My only problem with the dram was that the finish was a little short. The finish was extremely flavorful I just wish it would have lasted longer. Nose: Deep & Complex, currants, sherry, caramel Body: Dances on the tongue, lively Finish: Very subtle and short but extremely flavorful, wish it would last longer Complex and amazing.	Jeff - 90
Limited availability (try Park Avenue Liquors in Manhattan) $$$$$
Glenrothes                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Glen Rothes1994 12 year old Signatory
Glen - 85 This is a nice well balanced dram that lacked a wow factor but was still enjoyable. Had a long satisfying finish and put the dram over the top. You usually can't go wrong with Glenrothes and this one is no exception. Nose: Sharp, malty, oak, citrus and nutmeg Body: Light to medium Finish: Long and satisfying, lemon, oak and some malt A lovely finish.	Brett - 86 A classic Speyside. If you are a Glenrothes fan, it's all here for you, just tweaked a little. The nose, though sharper than usual, is still full of citrus (especially orange zest), with "oodles" of nutmeg and malt. There is an abundance of vanilla on the palate, but this Glenrothes is a little lighter, even thinner, than we were used to from this distillery. The finish picks this one back up, however. Very well-balanced; long and warming, with lemon and grapefruit at first, and a wafting of oak at the end.
Limited $$$
Glentauchers                                                                                                                                       Speyside
Glentauchers 14 year old Gordon & Macphail
Glen - 85 An easy drinking, flavorful malt from the Speyside region. Matured 14 years in oak casks, this dram has a soft, silky body making it an easy drinking everyday whisky. Nose: Soft. Lots of oak and vanilla, hints of clove Body: Medium & slightly oily Finish: Medium to long, vanilla dominates. Also citrus (oranges & grapefruit) A smooth easy drinking Speyside malt.	Jeff - 83
Limited availability $$
Inchgower                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Inchgower
Glen - 89 I was an Instant fan of this one. Great nose and finish that's a little untamed and wild. Has that coastal character that I love, like Scapa, Oban & Old Pulteney. Nose: Light, spirity, briny, some cloves, fresh Body: Medium, warming Finish: Dry, sweet, salty and has some bite A beautiful untamed gem!	Jeff - 88 A truly great undiscovered whisky, this salty spicy dram  is a true find for any collector wanting something a little different. The finish is a little short, but such a fresh tasting whisky. The smooth body with great character, If it was every released on a wide scale watch out.
Not Available in the US $$
Inchgower                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Inchgower Rare malts 27 year old 55.6%
Glen - 83 Jan, 2008 Inchgower has a very coastal character and this dram was no exception. Heavy on brine but still had a nice sweetness to add complexity. I still prefer the 14 year old Flora Fuana Inchgower expression over this one but any time I get to try a dram from this distillery is a good day. Reminder me of the Jersey shore. Salt from the sea and sugary snacks from the boardwalk vendors. Nose: Coastal brine, fresh, raspberry jam, vanilla Body: Medium Finish: Medium length and dominated by brine Sweet and Salty.	Jeff - 85
Limited $$$$
Knockando                                                                                                                                           Speyside
Knockando, 1990
Glen - 76 Jan, 2008 A very light dram that was pleasant but lacked any real depth. Refreshing and best enjoyed when you want an easy approachable dram. A very good dram for the beginner. Nose: Light, oak and malt dominate, nutty Body: Very light Finish: Short and dry, almond paste Refreshing. Rating: 76	Brett - 79
Not available in the US $$
Knockando                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Knockando, 1980, bottled 4-23-07, cask 1912, (46%) Duncan Taylor
Glen - 84 A good floral dram that I found enjoyable if not overly complex. Like sticking you face in a fresh floral arrangement. Not overly sweet and reminded me more of a Highland malt. My co-taster picked up more wet grass which I didn't find as prominent. The finish on this dram was exceptional. Nose: Fragrant floral notes, some grass and oak Body: Chewy Finish: Medium length, starts of hot and slowly fades away, burnt caramel, woody Lacks complexity but it's a good flavorful dram.	Brett - 74 The most straightforward of the bunch. The nose is extremely vegetal, full of wet grasses, with oak, caramel, and floral notes. This morphs into a medium, spicy palate, before ending with a short finish of caramel and hot wintergreen candy. We see this as a before-dinner aperitif.
Limited availability $$$
Linkwood                                                              Silent Still                                                          Speyside
Linkwood 20 year old Dun Bheagan
Glen - 86 A fresh easy drinking dram that has an awesome nose. The dram has a light floral character and a subtle light finish. A classic Speyside from this now closed distillery. Nose: Fresh, fruity, sweet, floral notes Body: light Finish: Subtle, barely there but flavorful, medium length Light, subtle and smooth. A classic Speyside	Jeff - 88
Difficult to find. $$$$
Linkwood                                                              Silent Still                                                          Speyside
Linkwood Rare Malts 1974 54.9%
Glen - 77 Dec, 2007 Very light and seemed to lack enough depth to warrant the hefty price. The nose was fruity with hints of pears and apples coming through. A floral character I couldn't nail down, like a working in your herb garden. Nice enough but the dram never grabbed me. Nose: Light, full of ripe fall fruit with apples and pears Body: Sharp and sweet Finish: Light and oaky Underwhelming	Jeff - 81
Difficult to find. $$$$
Longmorn                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Longmorn 15
Glen - 89 On of my favorite Speysides. It offers a wonderful smooth complexity and is one I always recommend. This is the dram I pour for company who are new to Scotch, they always come away impressed. Extremely flavorful and deep. A great elegant Speyside. Nose: Carmel, honey, toasted almonds (an exceptional nose) Body: Rich, creamy Finish: Sweet, toasted almonds, medium length  Highly recommended.	Jeff - 91 A truly great speyside, the first time you taste this dram,  you'll fell like your 18 again on your first date and the world is yours for the taking. Big fruity nose with a great sexy body, with a long finish that just doesn't want to end, nor do you want it too.
Available in some liquor stores. $$
Longmorn                                                                                                                                          Speyside
Longmorn 16
Glen - 74 This dram is replacing the Lognmorn 15 year old expression. The first thing that hits you with the new 16 year old is the updated packaging. The bottle has a catchy leather strap around the base and metal band around the neck. Although different, the bottle seems almost too desperate for attention. But who cares about packaging, what's in the bottle matters most, right? The new 16 year old expression was mostly malt with a sharp unbalanced finish. It wasn't a bad dram but it didn't come close to the dram it's replacing. It does get better as it stays in the glass and hints of vanilla and oak come through but not enough to compete with the all of the malt. The 15 year old was the type of dram you opened with friends and no one left until the bottle was empty. I'm said to say this updated version falls way short. Nose: Clean, soft, malt, oak and vanilla Body: Medium mouth feel, malty Finish: Long and unpleasantly sharp, all malt Unfortunately, the outside of the bottle is more impressive then what's under the cork. If you're a Longmorn fan try to horde the 15 year before all stock is gone.	Jeff -
Available in some liquor stores. $$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 10
Glen - 81 A little young, but a nice whisky but doesn't compare to the older Macallan's. This one is big on sherry.	Jeff - 86 I disagree with Glen to a degree with this one. I don't feel it is one of the best whiskies. But I do feel it's a good one none the less. Its has a beefy sherry flavor with a nice smooth fruity body. If you like sherry this is a good one to try and at a good price as well.
Available at all liquor stores. $$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 12
Glen - 77 If you're a Macallan fan, I'm sure you own a bottle or two of this one. This has all of the characteristics that made Macallan so popular among lovers of big sherry whiskies. Sherry on the nose with hints of vanilla extract, a rich body and sweet finish, it's all here. This was my Grandfather's favorite dram when he wanted to drink something special. Cheers, Pop Pop. Nose: Fresh, sherry, nutty, vanilla extract Body: Thick and rich Finish: Short with a bitter after taste, rich, sweet, sherry, subtle smoke, musty The standard Macallan.	Jeff - 86 I love big sherried drams and this one is right in that category. Lots of sherry but well balanced with some honey and a touch of smoke on the finish. Some oak and malt round it off.
Brett's Take: Rating 76 A youthful nose, full of simple syrup and vanilla beans. Also some wet walnuts and cloves to round it out. A medium-to-light body is followed abruptly by a finish of dry sherry, orange zest, and musk cologne. When I think of Macallan, this is the whisky I think of first. Widely Available. $$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 18
Glen - 89 This whisky is a real step up from the 12 year old, had a great comfortable feel to it. A rich spicy Macallan that is very flavorful and well balanced. This dram has a big rich nose highlighted by honey and vanilla. The body is full and the finish is medium length and warming. I think what I liked most about his dram is that the sherry isn't overpowering and lets other great flavors come through. First rate and very appealing. Nose: Sweet, subtle sherry, honey, slight peat, vanilla extract, leathery Body: Rich, medium to full Finish: Medium length and warming, sherry, oak, cloves, some bite Comforting.	Brett - 84 More complex than the 12-year-old, with a nose that explodes onto the senses: mild, sweet, with peach pits, heather honey, wet, tanned leather, vanilla, orange peel, and just the faintest hint of peat(?), this nose just sets-up the whole dram. A chewy, full-bodied mouthfeel precedes a taste/finish of toasted oak, more vanilla, sherry, and light spices. A little short, but this expression is exceptionally well-balanced.
Available at fine liquor stores. $$$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan Cask Strength (58.2%)
Glen - 83 A straight forward honest dram that I enjoyed. A little over sherried, but all in all it came off well balanced and flavorful. Had a nice burnt caramel and vanilla nose with a medium body and medium length complex finish. This is a cask strength whisky so make sure you add water. Nose: Burnt caramel, vanilla, sherry, oak, toasted nuts, clean Body: Medium Finish: Medium length, dry, fruit, some light peat, some bite Honest.	Brett - 83 Warm and deep, this whisky nosed wonderful burnt caramel, vanilla, and oak that, were it not for the omnipresent sherry, reminded us of fine bourbon. With water, there were light citrus notes, marzipan, and something that reminded me of a NY roasted nut cart. Like the 18-year-old, this expression was very well-balanced, with vanilla, oak, and heavy sherry on the palate. With water, it revealed more citrus (tangerines) in its medium-length finish.
Available at fine liquor stores. $$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 10 Fine Oak
Glen - 78 A young whisky that came off a little unbalanced but pleasant enough. The oak is pronounced and introduces you well into the Fine Oak range. This dram has a nice nose but the body is thin and the finish was medium length and fruity. One of my favorite Macallans is the Fine Oak 15 year old so I was a little disappointed with this dram's lake of balance and thin character. Nose: Vanilla, malty, hay, fresh Body: Thin Finish: Orange sorbet, dry, fruity, medium length Underwhelming.	Brett - 78 A fresh, very young nose, full of malt, hay, aldehyde, and vanilla. Also light honey, pineapple, and attic must. A thin, light body, opening into a short, warming, and oaky finish, with oranges and possibly candy canes. Some tasters swore they picked-up creamsicles, too. While not exactly balanced, this whisky could be the perfect introduction to the Fine Oak range.
Widely Available. $$ to $$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 15 Fine Oak
Glen - 88 The nose on this one is amazing with hints of vanilla and over ripe fruit. The fine oak range is very smooth and not as sherried as their standard line. Some subtle spice (nutmeg?) make for an impressive dram. This is a Macallan right up my alley. Nose: Vanilla, nutmeg, fruity, some citrus Body: Has some legs but not overly chewy Finish: Medium length and warming, apricots and Belgium chocolate If you own one Macallan, this should be the one, but I'm sure Jeff and Brett would disagree.	Jeff - 84 I don't love this one as much as Glen but it's a nice flavorful dram with tons of character. You can't go wrong with this one. It just doesn't taste like the Macallan that helped turn me on to single malt scotch.
Brett's Take: Rating 84 Sweeter and deeper than the F.O. 10-year-old, this whisky has delicious toffee notes playing against younger grassy notes. There is also that Macallan sweetness and orange aroma, as well as nutmeg, and what I can only compare to toast-and-butter (and what's better than that?). This whisky has a clean, medium-weight body, which suits it perfectly. And the finish…Long and lingering, sweet and smooth, nicely matching the nose, which, of course, is what you want. I picked-up caramel, more oranges, and a hint of milk chocolate. A fine whisky, before, during, or after a meal. Widely Available. $$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 17 Fine Oak
Glen - 76 As a big fan of the 15 year old I was excited about trying this dram. Maybe that's in part why I was so disappointed. Much more floral and the beautiful balance of the 15 year old is gone. Replaced by a very good nose that doesn't match the finish. Had a clinging candy sweetness in a short uninspired finish. The dram just never comes together. Nose: Musty, floral, malty, bourbon, burnt caramel, oak Body: medium to heavy Finish: Candy sweetness, very short, oranges A little muddled in the finish but the nose is superior.	Brett - 79 Very different than its 15-year-old cousin - much more floral, especially lavender, though there is still that burnt caramel sweetness and ever-present oak. The 17-year-old also has a medium body, maybe a little lighter than you might want, with a "shortish" finish of dried peaches, honey, light peat, and wet campfires.
Available at fine liquor stores. $$$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan 25
Glen - 89 This is usually a favorite for Macallan lovers and for good reason. The wine character is toned down and more smoke comes through that creates a Speyside of old. This is at the pinnacle for Speyside lovers. Complex, elegant but humble. Nose: Sherry, citrus, spice, fruity and smoke Body: Rich and big Finish: Long and dry, has some fruit and spice to balance the smoke Truly Impressive!	Jeff - 90 The best Macallan I've had. The sherry is balanced by smoke and dried fruity flavors. The perfect winter dram.
Available at some fine liquor stores. $$$$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan Replica Edition 1861
Glen - 92 The best Macallan I've had and truly a great one. You know your drinking something special. It's like you're in on a little secret that not many people know about. The only problem is that's impossible to find. If you're a Macallan fan, seek this one out at all costs. Nose: Spicy, sweet, oak Body: Medium, coats the mouth, thick Finish: Long and dry Exceptional!	Jeff - 91
Brett's Take: Rating 94 My favorite Macallan, which is saying something, given the overwhelming variety of whiskies put out by this classic distillery. The nose is like a lightly spicy maple syrup. It's got a warm heavy mouth feel that's sweet and fruity and almost chewy. And let's not forget that lingering finish. My only complaint—I can't buy a barrel!  Difficult to find. $$$$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Macallan, 1969, bottled 4-10-07, cask 8373 (44.6%) Duncan Taylor
Glen - 93 A wow whisky and one of the best Macallans I've had. Out of our three tasters, two of us loved this dram while the other thought the dram was aged a little long and imparted to much oak. I either love or hate Macallan, I can find no middle ground. This is one of the drams that I loved. The sherry dominates but you can taste the quality of the casks that were used in the maturation process. Smooth and complex and yet surprisingly easy going. A drink all day, finish the bottle type of whisky that oozed age and sophistication. I know what I want for Christmas! Nose: Clean, elegent, sherry, malt, honey, musty, reminded me of an old cozy pub Body: Medium to chewy, mouth coating Finish: Medium length, big at first and fades away nicely, oaky, spice, silky smooth A great whisky in the classic Macallan style.	Brett - 84 Now this is a BIG whisky! A favorite of two of our tasters, this dram was chock-full of sherry, but also contained strong honey notes, and that balsamic vinegar character that only happens when a sherried dram is aged well. The palate was, of course, very full-bodied, with flavors of cherry-pie filling, and (maybe) just a little too much oak. A long, soft finish helped complete the picture, slightly resinous, with oranges and grapefruits also in the mix. A quintessential "sipping whisky".
Limited. $$$$$
Macallan                                                                                                                                               Speyside
The Macallan 1990 17 yr old 46% (Small Batch) The Single Malts of Scotland www.thewhiskyexchange.com
Glen - 86 Jan 2008 A nice tasty dram that had that everyday dram quality to it. Fresh and clean with citrus and vanilla characteristics. The dram had a classic nose and a short but very flavorful finish. Nose: Fresh and clean, citrus mix, oak and malt, vanilla, floral Body: Thick and sweet Finish: Short and flavorful, dry, grassy, vanilla, caramel, cut grapefruit Tasty.	Brett -
Available at www.thewhiskyexchange.com $$ to $$$
Mannochmore                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Mannochmore 1991 13 year old Signatory
Glen - 91 By far the best Mannochmore more I've had and a must buy. My co-taster and I where thoroughly surprised and impressed with this big tough malt. Very complex with wonderful flavors constantly jumping out at you. This dram had an intense nose but once you got past the sharpness, you're hit with waves of milk chocolate, vanilla and nougat. Nose: Initially very strong, grassy and sharp, gives way to milk chocolate, vanilla, nougat and malt Body: Chewy and hot Finish: Medium length and the chocolate comes back, dried fruit, warming Highly recommended.	Brett - 89 A whisky man's whisky. Another Speyside, this is a wonderful dram for people who really appreciate whisky. The nose starts out pretty strong and grassy, but quickly morphs into a cereal grain maltiness, with vanilla, nougat, and definite milk chocolate notes. It has a hot, medium, slightly chewy body, and then blossoms with flavors of dried fruits, corn husks, and more milk chocolate sweetness. A very warming and satisfying dram.
Limited. $$$
Mannochmore                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Mannochmore 12 (Flora Fauna)
Glen - 80 A nice whisky that had an impressive lingering finish. The Flora Fauna range is one of our favorites and It's a crime that they aren't available in the US. This dram had a very light nose, a medium body, but a nice flavorful finish saves the day. Not the best Mannochmore I've had but a respectable dram all in all. Nose: Light, not very aromatic, some malt Body: Medium Finish: Sharp, medium length, lingering This one's all in the finish.	Jeff - 76
Not sold in the US. $$
Mortlach                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Mortlach 16 (Flora Fauna)
Glen - 94 Updated Nov 2008 In my opinion, this is one of the best whiskies in the world. The perfect Speyside, which offers rich, full flavor with amazing drinkability. By far the best of the Flora & Fauna line. It's almost criminal that Diageo doesn't offer a distillery bottling of this great whisky. Since most of the production goes into Johnnie Walker, this dram is difficult to find. If you can find it, horde it at all costs. Nose: Big and rich, floral, ripe Macintosh apples, almonds, sherry, oranges, touch of smoke, butterscotch coming through at the very end Body: Full Finish: Long and smoky balanced by sherry; warming A truly GREAT Speyside.	Jeff - 96 A great whisky that has it all, complexity well balance, just a  big sherried dram. A smooth lightly smoky finish. A truly great whisky. One I pour very gingerly when company is over.
Not Sold In US $$
Mortlach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Mortlach 1988 Signatory
Glen - 71 Spirity and a little rough around the edges. A decent honest dram that's not very distinctive. Mortlach truly shines when it's finished in sherry casks and this one is straight American Bourbon. Nose: Young & spirity, rough around the edges, deeper notes of vanilla Body: Light, fresh Finish: Dry, a little untamed, malty	Jeff - 74 A young grassy whisky aged only in American Bourbon. To me it's a little harsh but you'll pick up some nice nutty notes notes with a hint of sweetness. The body is pretty nice and light, but then the finish loses it for me.
Not widely available $$
Mortlach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Mortlach 15 year old Gordon & Macphail
Glen - 80 A nice dram with a short but flavorful finish. Easy drinking and smooth. Nose: Malty, oak, hints of vanilla and heather Body: light Finish: Short, flavorful, sweet, oak	Jeff - 79 The subtle floral hints are nice, but doesn't have that beefy chew on a steak like the Mortlach 16 flora fauna. This whisky has a nice nose with a nice smoke to it. Easy drinking smooth whisky. I wish the sherry was more pronounced.
Not Sold In US $$
Mortlach                                                                                                                                                 Speyside
Mortlach 17 year old Malt Trust
Glen - 88 A classic rich and syrupy Mortlach that stood up well to the 16 year old Flora Fuana expression that's in my top ten. Big, assertive and impressive, there is nothing like a Mortlach that's aged in sherry casks. The nose was fragrant with sherry, fruit and spices. The body was rich and syrupy while the finish was big and dry. A winner. Nose: Sherry, spices, fruity Body: Rich, syrupy Finish: Big, dry, sherry, holiday spiced cookies, long and flavorful A rich big sherry monster & a classic Mortlach.	Jeff - 83
Limited Availability (try Bayway in Elizabeth, NJ) $$$
Pebble Beach                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Pebble Beach 12 year old
Glen - 83 Dec, 2007 A very approachable easy drinking Speyside that should appeal to new whisky drinkers. The bottle doesn't indicate the distillery which is a tab annoying. If you are going to spend a premium price you should at least know the whiskies origin. Sweet and flavorful but lacks depth and complexity which in this case it seems perfectly fine. Refreshing and as the bottle indicates, perfect for the '19th' green. Nose: Sweet and rich, cherry pie, vanilla Body: Medium and has some legs Finish: Medium length and sweet, fruity A sweet treat.	Jeff - 78
Limited $$$
Speyburn                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Speyburn 10 year old
Glen - 76 A very sweet dram that's not too complex but easy drinking. Nose: Caramel, Butterscotch, fresh & sweet Body: Medium, has some legs Finish: Clean, sweet, distinctive and then leaves in a hurry Candy in a bottle!	Jeff - 70 A sweet whisky that taste to me a little like syrup. I find this whisky all over the place. I like its gentle body but I'm afraid it ends there. I wish the finish lingered a little longer.
Widely available $
Strathisla                                                                                                                                           Speyside
Strathisla 12
Glen - 85 Not very unique but something about it impressed me. I tried this whisky sitting on a covered porch in the pouring rain and the dram just seemed to fit. A good honest dram that I could drink all day. Nose: Not much on the nose, fruity Body: Medium, satisfying, fills the mouth Finish: Very smooth and short Smooth and easy drinking.	Jeff - 81 A very rich whisky, that is well rounded but needs something I just can't put my thumb on. Nice fruity vanilla body that pairs well with food.
Available at some liquor stores. $$
Strathisla                                                                                                                                               Speyside
Strathisla, 1967, bottled 6-19-06, cask 1896 (48.8%) Duncan Taylor
Glen - 84 A good rich dram that's sure to please. Very flavorful and complex. Stathisla is under appreciated and this dram is a great example of the fine whisky that this distillery can produce. My only complaint was that I found the finish a little short. The nose on this whisky was outstanding. Nose: Spicy (cloves), floral, sweet, red wine, rich Body: Rich Finish: Medium to short, hot, caramel, vanilla and oak A flavorful rich dram	Jeff - 81 An extremely complex nose that reminded me of wine because of its "grape" character, this Strathisla exploded onto the senses with olives, sponge cake, and clover. The best nose of the day (one man's view). The medium-weight body gave way to a hot, "shortish" finish, at times malty, at times oaky, but never boring, with beautiful caramel notes that weren't too sweet to drown-out the whisky. Nicely done.
Limited. $$$$
Strathmill                                                                                                                                            Speyside
Strathmill 12 Flora Fauna
Glen - 88 An exceptionally smooth and rich dram from the Flora Fauna range, this expression is a winner. A sherried whisky that's rich and flavorful without being overly sweet. The sherry was slightly more pronounced then I would have liked but this whisky is still very enjoyable. A very perfumed nose with ripe fruit and wine. I did pick up a slight hint of fish oil as well. The body is chewy and the finish is medium length smooth and dry. The Flora Fauna range seems to never disappoint. Nose: Perfumed, over rip fruit, wine, malt, nutty, fish oil Body: Chewy Finish: Flavorful and starts big, mellows to a smooth dryness, medium length Big and flavorful, Incredibly smooth.	Jeff - 88
Not available in the US $$
Tomintoul                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Tomintoul 10 year old 40%
Glen - 72 Dec, 2007 A very sharp, spirity dram that comes off much to young. Filled with oak and grass and lacks that sweetness you'd expect from a Speyside. Water improved the nose slightly but ruined the body and finish. Not very smooth. Nose: Very sharp, young and malty, grassy, spirity, musty, leather, honey and caramel Body: Medium to thick, sharp Sharp, a big burst and lingering, oak, some subtle smoke Maybe over ice?	Brett - 83 Dec, 2007 A very grassy nose; young and musty, but with a definite maltiness that sets it off. There is also caramel, and a butterscotch sweetness, as well as hints of old leather. The 10 year old can be a bit bitey on the palate, but also has a surprisingly medium/thick body, as well as a verrrry long, lingering finish. Big and strong, the finish contains a whole "forest full" of oak, with varying degrees of smoke, black tea, and more caramel. This is a big, everyday type of whisky that can be enjoyed year-round.
Widely available $$
Tomintoul                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Tomintoul 16 year old 40%
Glen - 79 Dec, 2007 This is a dram that improves immensely with water. I liked this whisky even though it still seemed a tad immature. Much smoother then the 10 year old and had a light wistful character. Nose: Grassy, young, heather, caramel and honey Body: Medium Finish: Medium length, bitters, oak, has a leathery aftertaste Pleasant with water.	Brett - 81 Dec, 2007 The 16 year old has a nose that we could only describe as "spirity". Full of old grasses and aldehyde, there are also hints of heather, sherry, and Tomintoul's trademark caramel. (Water really opens up the nose, exposing beautiful dried fruits and cinnamon.) A medium/light body segues into a finish that is both smoother and shorter than the 10 year old expression, with honey, toasted almonds, quinine, bitters, soft leather, and just the faintest, tiniest bit of peat (if at all). Though good, I wonder what a few more years in the cask would do to this dram.
Widely available $$ to $$$
Tomintoul                                                                                                                                             Speyside
Tomintoul 27 year old 40%
Glen - 86 Dec, 2007 Fruit salad anyone. Filled with overripe fruit with pears and apples in the nose and peaches in the finish. A unique perfumed nose. A fellow taster referred to it as a 'Bourbon light'. A very nice flavorful after dinner dram that was much better neat. Water removes the perfume and deadens the dram. Nose: Perfumed, tons of overripe fruit (mostly pears and crushed apples), caramel, oak Body: Very light Medium: Short, lots of peach, vanilla, honey, very sweet To borrow a quote from the Wiggles; 'fruit salad, yummy, yummy' (sorry I couldn't resist)	Brett - 87 Dec, 2007 Wow, what a nose! It is almost perfumed. Honestly. And though I'm not usually one for that sort of thing (preferring more of a "meaty" nose), this aroma is, pardon the obvious pun, intoxicating. Crisp and clean, the nose is also full of overripe pears and apples, as well as honey, light oak, and of course caramel. The very light body morphs into a short, sweet finish full of peaches, grapefruits, honey, vanilla, and light coffee. Very mellow. Though with different flavors, this dram reminded us of delicate bourbon, somehow. Truly the gentlest of the "gentle drams".
Widely available $$$